769: How To Interview After a Layoff: Stop Rehearsing and Build Trust

How to interview after a layoff: why rehearsed answers backfire, and how 10 stories and trust changed a banker’s results.

Listen

Guest

Ryan Schnoke, Senior Vice President, Data Analysis Manager

Ryan Schnoke is an analytics-driven strategy leader with senior-level experience translating complex data into clear, actionable insights that help business leaders make better decisions.

WATCH

what you’ll learn

  • Why rehearsing a perfect answer makes you sound rehearsed, and how Ryan figured that out
  • The 10-story method: write 10 experiences as stories and fit almost any question to one of them
  • Why an interview is about building trust in 30 to 60 minutes, and why being yourself is a better filter than being the best candidate
  • Why the holiday hiring slowdown is a myth, and what Ryan’s job search looked like before and after mid-December
  • How he handled an accepted offer and a call from his ideal company on the same day, including the conversation with his manager six weeks in

Success Stories

I’ve been offered the job! It was great having the opportunity to speak with you prior to my interview. It enabled me to highlight my strengths as part of the conversation and I was able to be clear about my enthusiasm for opportunities to be proactive versus reactive. I also highlighted my desire to provide positive individual experiences. Our discussion not only assisted me in the interview but it also helped to increase my confidence!

Bree Hunter, Project Officer, Australia

If you're looking for a change, if you're somebody who is feeling unsatisfied in your work, and you're not necessarily necessarily sure why that is yet, I feel like, that's a great way to kind of figure that out, just because of how the program is structured. I don't think that I would have necessarily gotten to where I am now without the program, especially when it came to the resume and the interviewing portion, because I feel like those are the hardest two areas for someone who's trying to switch into something that's completely different. Having that coaching and that information, and, you know, all those resources available to me to prep me for to be able to present myself in a way where, you know, I'm talking to the hiring managers, and they're like, hey, well, you know, she doesn't have, you know, experience in this, but, you know, being able to explain why I'm still a valuable person and why, you know, my other skills are still good fits for, you know, the job that I was applying for, I don't think I would have had that tools and that skill set and, you know, the roadmaps and the guidance that I would have, that I had with being part of the program. So I'm super, super grateful.

Alyson Thompson, Client Success Specialist, United States/Canada

[00:00:00] Ryan Schnoke: For the first 30 years, I liked getting up and going to work. For the last three years, I hated it

[00:00:04] Scott Anthony Barlow: The same bank, the same desk. What changed was the company around him.

[00:00:08] Ryan Schnoke: They started looking at us as assets more than people, I think.

[00:00:13] Scott Anthony Barlow: He saw it coming and he stayed anyway. But then the decision got taken away from him.

[00:00:18] Ryan Schnoke: I was ready to do all these things, and then my employer said, "You're out of here 'cause you don't matter to us anymore."

[00:00:23] Scott Anthony Barlow: So now he's out. He's got a master's degree, three decades of experience, and a severance clock running.

[00:00:28] Ryan Schnoke: Once I got past the initial surprise, the next emotion that came up was freedom, right? Oh, I'm free from this place that started to feel oppressive.

[00:00:37] Scott Anthony Barlow: That lasted about as long as you'd expect.

[00:00:41] Ryan Schnoke: Over time, when I just needed a job right away, that became a little oppressive too.

[00:00:45] Scott Anthony Barlow: Nine months, that's how long it took him to get back to a version of himself that he recognized.

[00:00:51] Ryan Schnoke: Had I not gotten pushed to it with that 33 years of comfort and history, would I have done it? I don't know. I don't know.

[00:00:58] Introduction: This is Happen To Your Career. Most people let their career happen to them, falling into jobs by accident, staying longer than they should, and wondering if this is really all there is. But a few people decide to stop settling and do something different. This podcast is for you to take control, get intentional, and design your career to fit the life that you want to build. Real stories and real research so you can stop waiting and start making it happen. I'm Scott Anthony Barlow.

[00:01:26] Scott Anthony Barlow: When's the last time you actually interviewed for a job in an incredibly genuine way, as who you are? Not, you know, not did the run around, not updated your resume, not played the interview game, but actually sat across from someone and told them who you are.

[00:01:42] You know, some people, it may have been never. Some people, it might've been years, and that feels fine. But what I find is that most people do not have the practice they need for these types of interactions to produce extraordinary results. Interviewing is a skill, and like most skills, not only if you don't use it, you lose it, but if you don't accelerate it, you can't be extraordinary at it.

[00:02:04] Now, Ryan found out all of this the hard way. He spent 33 years at one bank, started as a teller right out of high school, and eventually advanced through every position, every merger. And for the last 15 years, he ran analytics that allowed the bank to make decisions, and he was very, very good at it. He had room to be creative, and then he got laid off.

[00:02:25] So he had a master's degree, he had three decades of experience, he had 12 months on his severance clock, but he still hadn't been in interviews in well over a decade. So what do you do when you're in Ryan's situation? You're getting some interviews, you're getting some traction, but you're never actually getting into the final rounds.

[00:02:42] In this episode, we get to why overpreparing can actually make things worse, not better, and a 10-year story exercise that prepares you to walk into any interview already holding the answer. And what Ryan said after he was six weeks into a brand-new job that he had accepted, and the conversation he had with his boss when his dream company actually finally called.

[00:03:03] The question here isn't whether or not you're happy where you are; it's whether you could leave if you needed to or wanted to move to something even better. Here's Ryan.

[00:03:12] Ryan Schnoke: I started at a more local savings and loan back in the Kansas City area long, long ago. And went through several mergers and acquisitions and became part of a too-big-to-fail bank. And so over those years, I did everything from teller to banker to back office customer service to branch manager, government reporting, IT, all kinds of stuff.

[00:03:37] The last probably 15 years was concentrated on distribution analytics, is what we called it. So that was doing all the analytics around where we had branch locations, where we had ATM locations, where we opened them, closed them, moved them, upsized them, downsized them, all of that kind of work. So really just looking at, like, how we thought new locations would perform, how existing locations were performing, how merging them or moving them might change that performance, and how we would position them to serve our clientele best.

[00:04:17] So putting them in the locations where people wanted them, where they would use them, where they were in their daily life, so that it wasn't as necessarily a special trip to make it to the bank, but it was part of the route, and so it just added to what you could do for the day, right? And made it better.

[00:04:35] Scott Anthony Barlow: So throughout that time period, what was the version of the job that you enjoyed the most?

[00:04:43] Ryan Schnoke: I think the version of the job that I enjoyed the most is I got to be really creative with my analytics work. So I tended to fill the niche that they would have a vision of what they needed to do, but they would be unsure how to do it, and Ryan was the person that figured out how to make it work inside the infrastructure that we had.

[00:05:08] So we didn't always have the perfect tool, but I was really good at being able to creatively use the tools that were available to meet the need and do what needed to be done to get the task done. So probably the best example is I created a series of templates that they used to approve different kinds of plays with the branch.

[00:05:33] So if they wanted to open a new one, I had a template that would create, like, a 15-page document, would allow them to self-populate with a lot of information about the branches or the demographics around the location, and make sure that each case was presented in a way that made it so the executives focused on the decision rather than the documentation around the decision.

[00:05:57] And so I could be really creative with that, bring in different tools, and over those 10 years that product existed, just make it better, make it interact with more different things, add different levels of automation and different things like that. So it was a lot of fun, and something that I was really proud of creating and maintaining. A product that they used like that for more than 10 years is pretty amazing, actually.

[00:06:24] Scott Anthony Barlow: I think that's really cool, partially because it sounds like that you were the guy that when generally needed something done overall, you figured out how to connect all the systems and everything else together in order to get this done from your perspective. And then it sounds like what you loved about that was having the freedom to be really creative in how you did that.

[00:06:45] And it sounded like you had a lot of latitude to be able to just do it the way that you see fit. So I'm really curious, is that one of the pieces that kept you in place for 33 years? What kept you there at that organization? And did leaving ever cross your mind?

[00:07:00] Ryan Schnoke: It was a lot of different things, right? So yes, that was one thing that kept me in place. I would say for the first 30 years I was there, it was a great place to work that treated employees as people that mattered, that took care of us, that they were always flexible, and let me do the things that I needed to do. When my youngest was diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes, they let me do what I needed to do to manage that with her.

[00:07:27] So I did work at home mostly at that point in the position. But if I said, "Hey, I need to go up to the school because she's got a technology problem with her monitoring equipment," everybody always said, "Go. Take care of it. Do what you need to do," right? So they really treated us like we mattered, and the best way to say this, they enabled my life to work the way I needed it to, right?

[00:07:49] And over the last three and a half years that I was there, that changed quite a bit. They started looking at us as assets more than people, I think, and it became a place where as we... It was a group of people that had worked together for 15, 20 years, mostly in the department I was in that time, and as we would talk, we were all starting to see that change, and we were all starting to feel more miserable there.

[00:08:17] And then after COVID, they decided that, okay, everybody's gotta go back to the office. Never mind that you didn't work at the office before COVID. You've gotta go back to the office. So it just started being more like everybody's gotta check the boxes. Everybody's gotta do the things that the corporation says so we can look good to shareholders. The work that you do isn't what matters necessarily as much anymore as checking the boxes, and it just became a little overwhelming. For the first 30 years, I liked getting up and going to work. For the last three years, I hated it.

[00:08:55] And as part of that, they also started that return-to-office. They started figuring out how they were gonna use that to lay people off. So they started saying, "Oh, we're gonna call this location strategy. So if you don't live in these certain cities now, you're either gonna have to take a package or relocate to one of those cities."

[00:09:15] And so early on in one of the first phases, we saw a coworker who said, "Okay, I'll move to one of those cities so that I don't get laid off." And then about a year later, they got laid off anyway. So it really started telling you, "What? You know what? You don't matter anymore. We're just looking at the profits now, and we don't care about you."

[00:09:38] And it still didn't necessarily push me out the door, but it did make me start considering what my options were, right?

[00:09:45] Scott Anthony Barlow: I think that's an important distinction right there. So you had recognized these different signs as leadership changed over, and you started seeing these different types of decisions.

[00:09:56] And it's starting to conflict with some of that creative autonomy that you had enjoyed so much. And after seeing all of this writing on the wall, you're starting to consider would it make sense to leave in any way whatsoever, but not completely acting on that. And then it sounds like at some point, even though you felt like you were in a pretty safe position where you were, you ended up getting a call from your boss. What happened?

[00:10:19] Ryan Schnoke: So everybody knew the second Tuesday of the month was always the bad Tuesday, right? So that's the day that the layoffs came. From the location strategy, San Antonio was supposedly a safe city, so you could be here. You couldn't relocate here, but San Antonio wasn't a layoff place, right?

[00:10:37] So we were like a second tier market. So that was supposed to be safe, and we knew another round of the location layoffs were coming. I didn't expect to be included, but I did get that call from my manager.

[00:10:50] And because I'd been with the company so long, I knew that I was at the 12 months of severance. So I think that played into my decision not to try to move earlier than I did, because I'm like, "Hey, I might as well ride it out to the end. If I get the package, I've got a year to find a position." But I was thinking about where I wanted to go, what I wanted to do, those kind of things.

[00:11:14] My Covid crazy decision was I went back to school and got my master's degree in data analytics. So I knew I had that skill set in my back pocket, and I didn't really feel like I was getting to use it at that level where I was at. So those were kind of some of the things that factored in my wait-and-see part of the decision.

[00:11:33] Scott Anthony Barlow: Well, and if I remember correctly too, as you'd been thinking about, you know, hey, there's the potential to get laid off, and if that happens, we'll ride it to the end, and you have 12 months severance. But also there's this other factor there that, if I'm not mistaken, you had sort of considered the time period where your youngest had started college as the time period in which you would do something different or start acting on it. How did it end up working out?

[00:12:02] Ryan Schnoke: She was supposed to start school in August, right? And so I got the call in July that I was going to be displaced, right? So the way that worked, and yes, I was already thinking in the back of my head, "Let's get her off to college, and then I'll start really actively looking," right?

[00:12:23] So it pushed my timeframe up a little bit, but in hindsight, I think it was the push that I needed to get over that, 'cause it, it was time for me to go because that was the only way I was gonna grow at that point, was to move on to somewhere else, I think, right? And there was probably 50-ish people in the group that I was in, and there's maybe five or six of those people left, so it's been a pretty drastic turnover in those couple of years since then.

[00:12:48] So yes, I guess the positives out of it were it did let me get her off to school. She's going 12 hours away to college. It let me have a little flexibility in those first few months she was there to go see her more and make sure she was set up for success and able to enjoy the start of her college journey, right?

[00:13:07] So that timing was okay. But you can look at it from the opposite perspective, saying, "I was ready to do all these things", and then my employer said, "You're out of here 'cause you don't matter to us anymore."

[00:13:17] Scott Anthony Barlow: Yeah. I think the interesting thing for me is here at Happen to Your Career, we obviously get to interact with and work with many people that are in situations that they didn't necessarily choose.

[00:13:28] Either because of layoff or because something changed in their workplace, or whatever else it is. But I think the really fascinating thing in your situation is right down to just be, like, two months away from when you were already going to do something to some degree, that's pretty close.

[00:13:44] That's pretty close. People say there's no good time to get laid off, and I tend to agree having been through both sides of that. But yours was pretty close.

[00:13:54] Ryan Schnoke: That was the plan in the back of my head, but had I not gotten pushed to it with that 33 years of comfort and history, would I have done it? I don't know. I don't know.

[00:14:04] Scott Anthony Barlow: That's where I was gonna end up going with that. Yeah. That's what I was curious about.

[00:14:07] When you were thinking about that, though, just even the idea in back of your head How did it feel at the prospect of just starting with a new organization, even when you were just thinking about it? Was that scary? What was that like?

[00:14:21] Ryan Schnoke: I think scary is the right word, right? It's just that fear of the unknown. I've been here so long. I'm comfortable with it. It's like that old comfy pair of shoes that you should have thrown away, but you didn't because they're so comfortable, right?

[00:14:34] So yes, definitely scary. Cause a lot of apprehension. Just I think the life events that were going on made it more scary. But everybody would probably say that about the life situation they're in, right? It was unexpected, although I knew it was a possibility that was out there on the horizon.

[00:14:54] Scott Anthony Barlow: Has that actually happened and it became a reality that you were going to make a transition? Did you become more okay with that or did it continue to have the same level of scariness or fear or however we want to refer to that?

[00:15:09] Ryan Schnoke: I think that, you know, once I got past the initial surprise and trepidation around what I was going to do, I think the next emotion that came up was freedom, right? Oh, I'm free from this place that started to feel oppressive, that started to feel like they were holding me back, not treating me well, all of those kind of things. So that was just a couple days that it took to get to that point of, oh, wait a minute, this is a breath of fresh air.

[00:15:36] So now I have an opportunity, and I'm out of that environment, and that, because when you're in that environment, you've got to work the 8, 9, 10 hours a day, so it kind of holds you back from the opportunity of looking as much, right? It's not that you can't look, but it's harder because you have less time.

[00:15:54] Just having that availability and the opportunity to go out there and really make my full-time job finding my next full-time job was a little liberating at the start. And yes, over time, when I didn't get a job right away, that became a little oppressive, too. But I made it work for me and really started to figure out how, you know...

[00:16:17] I think upfront, like one of the things is, okay, what do I want to be when I grow up? I still didn't know, although I was plenty old enough and plenty grown up enough that I should. But just figuring out, like, what's that perfect role for me? What's that thing that I would do if I wasn't getting paid? What's that thing that's gonna really satisfy me and let me contribute to an [00:16:40] organization at the same time?

[00:16:40] Scott Anthony Barlow: I think those are really great questions, and I would argue that those are far better questions that we have received over the years, where people say, "I know I should probably have figured out what I want to be when I grow up."

[00:16:51] And I think that in itself is, you used the word oppressive earlier. But I think that idea that somehow we should have figured out this thing that we're gonna do forever is not necessarily as useful, even though it hits us in various different ways ever since, like, you know, I've got a kid, youngest, who just turned 16.

[00:17:10] And people are asking them, like, "Hey, what do you want to be when you grow up?" We're putting that pressure on people pretty early to have everything all figured out, let alone much later. But the thing I think that is interesting for you is, even though that was in the back of your head, you started asking far better questions.

[00:17:29] Like, what is going to feel different at work? What are the ways that I want to utilize my skills or contribute or spend my time? As you were starting to shift into that type of thinking, what was most challenging for you when you're starting to think about it that way and try to determine where and how do I want to find my next step in the real world?

[00:17:49] Ryan Schnoke: Right. So I was in the banking world for all of those 33 years. Started pretty much right out of high school. I think I was 19 or 20 when I started in the banking world, right? And so do I want to stay in that world? Is that the right world? 'Cause data analytics skills are fairly transferable. They don't have to be industry specific, right?

[00:18:09] Yes, I understand banking accounts, banking products, banking regulations. So I understand kind of that external factors that impact the data and the analytics sometimes, but for the most part, the skills were fairly transferable, right? Really, I think one of the first things was just figuring out what world do I wanna look in, and I was satisfied being in the banking world.

[00:18:31] There's some, some nice things about that. So I didn't exclude that as a possibility for my next position, but I started to look at what other industries would make sense for me to look in, and what other industries might I enjoy being a part of, right? And so that made my search a little broader, because I didn't have to narrow it down to just one industry. So that was kinda nice.

[00:18:58] And I did have a few interviews outside the banking world, but I think based on time in the industry and where I was at in my career, that's where most of the interest was coming from, and that's where most of the calls that I would get after submitting applications and stuff came from. So I did, over time, kinda make that my main focus, but I did look at interesting jobs outside all the way up to the end to just see what made sense.

[00:19:27] Scott Anthony Barlow: When you were thinking about making this change, how were you thinking about your timeframes around this? Did you have specific goals that you said, "Hey, I wanna make this transition during this particular time period," or was it as long as it takes to find it? How were you thinking about that going into it?

[00:19:43] Ryan Schnoke: Yeah, that's a great question. The way that it kinda played out was that, so I got the notice in July, and so the first part of that was you've got notice that you're gonna be laid off in 60 days. And so in those 60 days, it was kind of manager's discretion how long you have to work, how long you don't have to work, and my manager was like, "You can work two weeks, and then you're out of here."

[00:20:07] So I still got that 60 days of pay pushing me into September, and that's when the 12-month severance period started. During that 60-day period, I really looked at that as, "Hey, I've got a year after this is over, so let's take some time to reflect. Let's take some time to plan." And the biggest thing was let's take some time to get my daughter off to school and not be stressed about this, right?

[00:20:31] So let's kinda let life happen the way it was going to because I have some flexibility. And so that was kind of a nice piece of it. And then really once we got her moved off to school, when that September period rolled around, that's where I really looked at, "Okay, so let's start looking at what my resume looks like, what resources I have to help me with my resume, what job searches I can set up, what tools I should be using," 'cause I had been a bad adult in that I hadn't really nurtured that part of my professional career over the last several years.

[00:21:09] So yes, I knew LinkedIn was out there, but did I use it? Not really. So I knew about all those other things as well, and job search agents and what some of the different platforms were, but I had never really used a lot of them. I took the time to get to know all of those different platforms, what is out there, what seems realistic.

[00:21:29] A new one was how I could use AI in my search. So how can I use AI to make myself look like the right candidate for the job? And yes, you could do that very easily with AI, but at the same time not lie about who I was, 'cause I'm gonna get found out if I get an interview if I'm not telling the truth.

[00:21:48] Sometimes you would even have to rein the AI in, but just figuring out how all of those things worked and really having kinda like my own baseline for the job search, I think. That probably took another month or two.So now we're in, let's say, late October, early November, and now I'm pretty much ready.

[00:22:09] But I know it's probably not the best time because now people are, "Oh, we're not that interested in hiring 'cause it's the holidays and the end of the year," and that kind of stuff. But I didn't let that stop me. I thought that's something that still gives me maybe even a little more flexibility to look and apply and not get too worried when I don't hear right away.

[00:22:29] And it was kind of interesting because, like that first month that I really started sending out resumes and applying for things, I didn't hear back from anything, right? So I was almost at the point of getting, like, really discouraged. I think my resume's looking pretty good. I think this is happening, but I'm not hearing anything back.

[00:22:50] And then, like, mid-December, like, the emails and the calls started coming back. "Okay, we gotta start because we know we're gonna hire after January gets here." So it was almost like there was probably a natural pause that I hadn't anticipated, that almost let get me really frustrated, and then it played out to work in the long run.

[00:23:10] Scott Anthony Barlow: I think that's a really important distinction for people to understand, though. There's so much of this pervasive, I'm gonna call it misinformation, that you should just shut down your job search as November and then pick it back up in January. However, just like you found, there are drastically different activities going on, and different cycles for different organizations.

[00:23:30] And for some of those organizations, that's exactly when they need to start working on it so that they can have a hire in January. And for other organizations, completely different. But I've always found that since everybody else thinks it's a terrible time to move forward with a career transition, then that spells opportunity because you have, all of a sudden, no competition, because it dips off, and that creates other different types of opportunities that just people don't consider.

[00:23:55] So kudos to you for not allowing that information to stop you. Nicely done. As you were getting into interviews, because at that point, you started to get into different types of interactions and interviews with various organizations.

[00:24:10] And if I remember correctly, you would have some of those initial interviews, whether it be a screening interview, first interview, whatever it is, and you didn't feel like you were getting past those at first. What was going on? And why do you think that was happening?

[00:24:24] Ryan Schnoke: I think the biggest thing is I honestly hadn't interviewed for jobs in 10 years, right? I was comfortable where I was at. My lifestyle was enabled that worked, and so I just hadn't applied for anything internally, externally. Hadn't interviewed for anything. Hadn't practiced those skills in 10 years. And so I think that was a big piece of it. And even though we got provided some basic coaching, job search, and it was okay quality, and you could get 30 minutes here, 30 minutes there.

[00:24:57] But probably the point I was at in my career, in hindsight, that probably wasn't enough. And I probably should have called you guys sooner, but I didn't, so we dealt with it. So yes, that's exactly what I was finding. The first couple of times, like I bombed the HR screen, right? I don't know what to say. And so then I could reflect on kinda how those went, and then the next kinda series of interviews that I got set up for did pretty well on the HR screen.

[00:25:28] Got to the first level interview and would bomb that one. Reflect on that, learned. So the next set of interviews, I could get through those first two, and then would get to the hiring manager and kinda bomb something on that, and kinda reflect. And then I think it was just at that point, I think I had kinda each different set of interviews figured out a little better.

[00:25:51] And what was challenging was stringing them all together. And I think what's hard is because every company does it in a different order, or it puts a different priority on them, or, "Oh yeah, this time we want you to sit with six people who will be your peers to see how you'll fit into the group."

[00:26:11] And then the next one doesn't do that when you get closer to the end, and they wanna be more specific and have you with just this one person. Or then one has me like, "Oh, we want you to come have an interview with the people that will be working for you." So just all kinds of different things, and some of those kind of more not normal interviews were the hardest ones to prepare for.

[00:26:34] So I didn't feel like I ever developed the proper approach to preparing for them, because I felt like beforehand I was prepared, but afterwards, I would be like, "Ugh, I should have done this and that," and I wasn't prepared. So I think it was... And honestly, I don't think it was my preparation that was the problem, I think it was just that I let it make me lose confidence in my ability to do it well.

[00:27:01] Scott Anthony Barlow: Yeah. There's this really interesting set of research specifically about interviews or interview-like situations, and the idea was attempting to measure confidence going into, like how confident are you? Because there's also quite a bit of research out there that the more confident people feel going into different situations, for the most part, they tend to perform better.

[00:27:26] That's not true in all situations like driving, but for the most part, these types of interview interactions, that's what we see. But I think the fascinating part is people who would take the time and energy to prepare and practice in one of a few different practice methodologies would come out of the practice approximately 50% more confident.

[00:27:49] Okay. And then that would translate into the actual interactions for interviews too. And so that's not a surprise to any of us. Like, you practice more, you get more confident. Like, there's no surprise learnings there. However, we all know that, and we don't necessarily do that.

[00:28:04] So my question to you is, for you, in your experience, what do you think started to make those interview interactions easier and where you started to carry some of that confidence with you? What did you need to do personally? What did that look like?

[00:28:18] Ryan Schnoke: I'm gonna take one step back from that before I get there. I think that I had gotten to the point where I was probably over-preparing, so spending too much time. And the reason why is I had convinced myself that I had to have the perfect answer for every question.

[00:28:39] And so I was trying to rehearse them so that I could get this perfect answer, and it was probably coming off as rehearsed, which is not good. That's not what I want, right? And that's kinda how I felt like I had got to at that point, because I had reached that point of discouragement where, "Why am I not getting a job offer? Now I have to be perfect."

[00:29:02] And I kinda hit a lull in interviews where I didn't get anything for, like, six weeks, and I was probably seven months into my severance period by then. So now I'm starting to get worried, and that's when I reached out to Happen To Your Career. That's when you got to meet me, and I think there's two really important things that Mel said to me that made all the difference and turned the process around for me.

[00:29:31] So I think the first thing that helped me get over that needing to have the perfect answer, because where I would be in an interview is like, "Oh, let me think. What's the perfect situation for that?" And I would struggle to get it. And so Mel said, "Well, let's take your experience. You've got tons of experience over 33 years, so your challenge is probably that you have so many experiences that you're struggling to figure out which one's perfect.

[00:29:57] So let's pick 10. Write them down. Write the story. And what you're gonna find when you have your 10 stories is that almost any question that somebody asks you fits into one of those 10 stories. So now you don't have to think so broadly, and you don't have to stress in your interview about, 'Oh, what's the story, though, I'm gonna tell?' You'll know that one of these 10 will work for the question that you're asked, and you just have to figure out which part of the story is relevant to the question."

[00:30:30] So that was the first thing that really helped me, because it let me be more confident that I had an answer in each interview, right? And then the second thing that Mel said to me, which I think was what really made the difference for me, was, "When you're interviewing with people, they're not looking for the perfect answer, they're looking to see can they trust you. And so in an interview, what you need to do is build that trust relationship."

[00:31:01] And yes, maybe you've only got 30 minutes, maybe you've only got 60 minutes, but it's very possible to do that within that time frame And that, as we worked through that, for me was being genuine, being myself, and if me myself wasn't the right person for the job, that was okay. But that's what helped me start connecting to the people that I was interviewing with in all the cases.

[00:31:28] Scott Anthony Barlow: Couple really important things that you said that I don't just wanna gloss over 'cause it's easy to miss. Number one, instead of taking the approach around, "Hey, how do I prep for all the anticipated questions?"

[00:31:40] Which is impossible. Like, there are certain organizations that ask the exact same questions for the exact same positions every single time. However, even then, I would argue it's not a effective approach because what you said, you tend to get over-prepped and then you don't come off as genuine.

[00:31:54] And it feels bad, too. It feels like this contrived situation. So your best self doesn't come out. But I think the other thing that you said, too, that was really critical is if you didn't get hired or didn't move forward because of something that just truly wasn't a fit for you, what you're looking for or who you are, then that was okay.

[00:32:14] You were okay with that. And I would argue that is the reason that we do interviews when we are doing them well, when they work best in that type of situation. It is about that exploration to find a fit, which I know there's so much minutia on top of it that makes it hard. Didn't wanna gloss over that because you said something really important there.

[00:32:32] What advice would you give to somebody else who is finding themselves in this situation where maybe they're starting to get traction, they're getting interactions or interviews, or getting to have those types of conversations, but they're not necessarily moving through, they're not necessarily consistently getting offers?

[00:32:49] Ryan Schnoke: There was plenty of other people that went through this process at my employer with me, right? So some of them have gotten positions, some of them are still looking, some of them were in a later phase than me or an earlier phase than me. And so as I've talked to many of them, I think the biggest advice that I've given them that they found helpful is the whole building trust thing, and how critical that is to just be who you are.

[00:33:16] Don't try to be the candidate that looks [00:33:20] best. Don't be what you think they're looking for. Just be you and be honest and build that trust. And that trust goes both ways, too, right? Like, through that interview, you should also be figuring out, "Hey, this is somebody that I can trust to treat me right." So I think it goes both ways.

[00:33:40] And while we may get to the point where yes, we feel like we need to get a job today, we don't wanna get the wrong job and be right back in this situation. So try to be as patient as you can and try to focus on finding that right spot and don't sell yourself short and take just anything that's out there.

[00:34:00] Scott Anthony Barlow: I think that's really solid advice. And the other thing that has always guided me over the years is the simple logic that if I'm not being who I am, I get hired, then that means that they've hired me for who I was, you know, pretending to be in that interaction. Which that's me, that's on me misrepresenting myself.

[00:34:19] There was a particular interview along the way, a panel interview, when you got short in breath in one of the first questions. Can you tell me about what happened?

[00:34:30] Ryan Schnoke: It probably happened a few times, and I think it's a couple things going on, right? Like, early on when it wasn't going well and I would find myself in that situation, I think it was because I'm trying to look for that perfect answer.

[00:34:45] And so I'm hurrying my answer to try to get it all in and not be too long, 'cause, you know, everything says not longer than three minutes or whatever, right? So tell your story, tell it in a short amount of time, and just kind of following all those rules. Trying to think, trying to read the room, being nervous, and just kind of letting that take you to telling the stories too fast.

[00:35:14] So they're probably not being heard very well, one. You're not... I wasn't being the genuine me because I was being hurried in there, right? But it was from my own head that was hurrying me. It wasn't the interviews that were hurrying me, it was my own head. And so I got through the story because I was trying to remember all the points that I wanted to say or trying to give the rehearsed answer in the exact way that I had written it down, and AI had told me I needed to say it, and all the prompts say, "Do it this way."

[00:35:41] So trying to remember all those things and being stressed, and you get to the end of it and you're like, "Oh, wait, I can't breathe." 'Cause I was just going too fast and trying to think about those things. And so I think it communicated that I was rehearsed, that I wasn't confident, that I wasn't being myself, right?

[00:35:58] So I think it immediately told people that, "Oh, maybe he's trying to hide something. Maybe he's trying to do this. Maybe he's trying to be something that he's not." So I think that's kind of where that left me. Now, ironically, for the position that I'm in now, I found myself with that like after the tell us about yourself question at the start, I found myself kind of in the same situation. I'm like, "Oh, I'm breathing hard," right? But it was because I was excited.

[00:36:27] Scott Anthony Barlow: Interesting. Did you notice that real time?

[00:36:29] Ryan Schnoke: At the end of the question, I noticed it, right? And I actually acknowledged it. I'm like, "Oh, I'm sorry, I'm out of breath. I got a little too excited about that answer." But it was the same kind of place, but for a very different reason. And in the other times that it happened, it really threw me off. And really sabotaged the rest of the interview because of how it's at that point. Where in this interview for this position, it was like, oh, I acknowledged it, I felt good about it, and it's because I was excited about it, not because, you know...

[00:37:03] So I think although it felt the same a little bit, it was two different reasonings, and it left me in a different spot for both of them.

[00:37:11] Scott Anthony Barlow: That's fascinating. Like, it's easy to sit here and talk about that afterwards. It's actually really difficult to do the level of preparation and practicing and everything else that goes into it to get to the point where you're observing that real time as it's happening, paying attention to it, and then able to articulate it, yeah, during the interview in a way that becomes additive to the interview as opposed to disruptive. I think everybody just has this idea, like, "I'm supposed to be a good interviewer," or, "I'm not."

[00:37:37] And there are these levels of nuance and practice and skillsets that build skillset upon skillset that tend to build on one another that make all of this easier for these types of interactions. If we fast-forward a bit and you got one offer while at the same time you were just really starting to get into interviews and interactions with another company that you were really interested in.

[00:38:04] And that, I think, is a super fun place to be. Not everybody in the world gets to participate in that. There's a lot of work here that went in to create that situation for you at that moment. But I'm curious what happened there and what caused you to make some of the decisions that you did?

[00:38:22] Ryan Schnoke: When I looked at what my options were and started trying to get more specific about halfway through my severance period, right? It became clear that I could look for two different types of jobs. So type one was a job similar to what I had, doing analytics in the way that I was. And the second option was to go towards my master's degree and really look for hardcore data scientist positions, 'cause that's what my degree let me be, is a data scientist, right?

[00:38:53] And so I kinda started separating my job search into those two pieces, right? Like, okay, let's look for the data science jobs, and let's look for the data analytics jobs, and let's kinda see where that plays out.

[00:39:07] It helped me refine my interviewing a little bit more and my resumes a little bit more to know, let's be specific on which one I'm looking for. A well-known company here in San Antonio was doing a lot of work around data science, and so they had kinda actually even divided it into a few things of data science, decision science, and data analysis.

[00:39:30] And so the position that I applied for there was in decision science. So call it somewhere between data science and data analytics, right? And so it was really the perfect type of role for transitioning to what I had done in the past and really using my master's degree on a full-time basis, right? So really a perfect opportunity to do that.

[00:39:56] So I applied for several positions there and got several different interviews with different groups that were hiring these people, and I think that's where I started using a lot of what Mel and I had been working on. So I really... I got one interview. I felt really confident in my skill set. I really connected with the interviewer.

[00:40:16] So it was a panel interview with three different hiring managers all looking for somebody for this role, right? It was kinda like three interviews in one almost, right? So interviewed for that. Really felt good about all three of the managers, and I connected well with them. And I learned later... So I did get an offer from them, and I did accept the offer, and I started working for them.

[00:40:38] And once I was there, I learned that they were kind of... I wouldn't say they were fighting over me, but they were trying to figure out which one... You know, they all would've been happy to hire me. They were trying to figure out where would be the best fit for me and for them. But got on a team. It was a great opportunity. I was really enjoying it. The same day I accepted that position, I got a call from the recruiter for the job that I now have, and it was a position that was more utilizing the skills that I had been doing in data analytics for the past 15 years, and probably something a little more data science than what I had been doing, but not like I was doing in the decision science position.

[00:41:19] So it was at the company that when I got laid off I said, "That's the company I wanna go work for." So I had applied for, I think, 13 positions there. I had probably interviewed for eight or nine of them. None of them were the perfect fit. I think I could have done all of them and done well at them, but there was like, you know, "Oh, I don't have this one piece of experience that doesn't make me the perfect candidate."

[00:41:43] This role, like, it checked all my boxes. I think I checked all their boxes. It was like, wow, this is the perfect position for me. But I just accepted this job over here. I started the new position, and I started interviewing for the position that I now have at the same time. So it's a little funny 'cause you're like, "Oh, I feel bad about doing that," but I do have to look out for me and my family, right?

[00:42:07] So I had taken a little bit of a pay cut from my previous role to get into the decision science position, and I was okay with that 'cause it let me transition into where my master's degree was. So not the best position to have to take a little bit of a pay cut to get there, but I was okay with it for that position.

[00:42:25] I wouldn't have been okay with it for the job that leveraged my data analytics skills that I had been doing. It was a great place to be. It was a great company. I was really enjoying the relationships with the people I was there with and the job I was doing. But this role that I ended up accepting after I had been at the new company for six weeks, so that was a great fun conversation to go to my manager and say, "I know I've been here for six weeks, but I'm leaving." But was really a great fit, and it allowed me to find the position that I wanted.

[00:42:55] Scott Anthony Barlow: I think this is an area where you did a great job building trust. You mentioned earlier you shifted your focus to really building trust during the interview process, and then also creating that environment or situation to where they felt like they could trust you.

[00:43:12] So that became the focus at some point. And I think that once we got into these interactions where you had accepted an offer, you're having a conversation with your boss because another company had given you an offer, and you recognized that was an even better fit and it was the organization that you'd been pursuing from the very beginning, I think how this got handled really reflected how well you built trust.

[00:43:39] So can you share a little bit about what that conversation was like? What did you say? What did you do? What did, you know, your boss over at the company that you're now putting in your notice at this point in time? How did that go?

[00:43:50] Ryan Schnoke: Yeah. It's a great question because, yeah, I built trust, and then you could say I ruined the trust at the same time, right?

[00:43:56] Because I left so quickly, but that's not how it happened, right? And it didn't happen that way because- I was upfront all the way along, and when I accepted the position, I tried to negotiate up and didn't get to where I wanted to be. Had I gotten there, I probably... Would I have taken this job? I don't know. It would've been a little harder decision.

[00:44:19] But I was very upfront with all that, so when I got there, went through orientation and got to spend some time with my boss, it's like, "Hey, this is where I'm at. This is what I accepted to take this position. I am very interested in doing it, but we need to put me on the track to move me ahead and get me to a higher salary and a better position at the same time.

[00:44:41] So let's work towards that." I don't know if I ever said I'm still looking, but I made it fairly obvious that I needed more to move forward. And so I don't feel like I violated that trust with him, and I still talk to him actually. And I met him out for dinner or for lunch once in a while, right? So still have a good relationship with them, and it was just staying honest and not trying to hide the fact of what was going on.

[00:45:06] And his reaction was even, when I told him, he was like, "Oh, I'm not surprised." So I had set those expectations, right? That I like it here, but I need more. So I didn't feel like I violated any of my own thoughts or expectations of myself to do that. I don't feel like I was slimy in doing that.

[00:45:28] Scott Anthony Barlow: I think that's phenomenal, and also really difficult to do in reality, just because we feel like we need to hide some of those pieces. When in reality, as you have many of those types of interactions and conversations, it becomes obvious that no, it's actually not helpful to hide that. In fact, it's more beneficial to everybody to be able to share that upfront for exactly this type of situation, which could happen in the future, or many others that we're not talking.

[00:45:55] One of the questions that comes up for me is you had identified this other organization from the very beginning as the organization that you most wanted to work with. Why was that? Why did you feel so strongly that this organization lined up so well for you?

[00:46:13] Ryan Schnoke: Yeah. So everything that I had ever heard about this company was that they treated their employees correctly, they valued their employees and the contribution that they made to the company and the bottom line, and that it really felt like being family instead of being an employee, right?

[00:46:32] All of the values that they tell you that they have on the outside, what I found from the inside, which is also what people were telling me, are exactly the values that they have. How they advertise themselves as an employer is true, and there's nothing that they're really hiding. And so it's a place that I can feel proud to say I work there.

[00:46:53] It's a place that when I tell people in San Antonio that I work there, they're like, "Oh, I wish I could work there." So that's the reputation that they have, and it's been a true reputation. So it's a 158-year-old company, and they follow those beliefs for 158 years and been very straightforward with them, and it feels really nice to be in that environment.

[00:47:15] Scott Anthony Barlow: What about if you could say, "Hey, here's the two or three things that really made this particular role a really strong fit and much closer to your ideal" what are those? Because you said yourself that you interviewed and looked at many other opportunities at that same organization but they weren't quite a fit.

[00:47:36] Ryan Schnoke: So this one, the basic expectations for the job really played into my strengths and my experiences. So as I was going through the job description and looking at all the requirements, like every single one of them I had experience with, every single one of them I had fit with, so there was nothing that I was really missing.

[00:47:58] And then when I had my first interview with the HR person, I connected to her really well, and that's another point about this company. So the very first job I interviewed for, I stayed in touch with that HR rep. She was never the HR rep on any of the other positions I interviewed for, but she was great and amazing.

[00:48:20] And so when I would apply for something, I would say, "Hey, I applied for this job," 'cause I connected with her well, right? And so she would send me to that HR person and say, "Hey, Ryan applied for this job. I think he'd be a good fit." So she helped me get other interviews, right? So that was my first experience with the actual culture, and I found that amazing 'cause in most jobs, HR didn't even follow up with you, much less remember who you were.

[00:48:44] And it's not everywhere, though. Unfortunately, it's not where I'm at now. But it was amazing just to get that level of involvement from that HR person. I even wrote her an email a couple weeks after I'd gotten hired saying, "I know it wasn't your job, but I don't think I would've gotten it without you," 'cause I probably would've given up, honestly.

[00:49:00] I don't know if I would've applied for this one. I might have been done with the company if it wasn't for the fact of how engaged she was in jobs that she wasn't even hired for, right? So that was an amazing connection into it as well. And then when I had my hiring manager interview, I just connected with her really well, too, right?

[00:49:20] And I think that was a result of all the things that we've been talking about. It was the result of just knowing my background, knowing the stories that I have that work for the jobs that I'm applying for, and most importantly, building trust was the key, I think, with her.

[00:49:39] Scott Anthony Barlow: When you think back, what has this process and going through this transition, what has it taught you and what surprised you the most?

[00:49:48] Ryan Schnoke: I think probably the biggest thing that it taught me, and interestingly it was... So when I was in my little eight-week tenure at the previous employer, one of the [00:50:00] managers that I had interviewed with, I sat down and talked to, he said, "I encourage you to continually apply for positions and interview," which was the opposite of how I had done it, right?

[00:50:12] Like he said, "Make sure you keep those skills because those are skills you need over time. And so even if you're really not interested in leaving, there's nothing wrong with applying and interviewing." And so I think that's a big takeaway for me because what that's saying is always be prepared for that, right?

[00:50:30] And always make sure you're building those skills rather than losing those skills or letting those skills stagnate. Because the market changes. The way people interview changes. The questions that they ask change. The philosophies change. So if you're not out there being an active participant, then it makes you stale and struggle, and it took me nine months to kinda get back to being confident and being prepared to do interviews, where if I was doing them all along, it probably would've been a much quicker, shorter job search.

[00:51:12] Scott Anthony Barlow: What's different today in your life or in the role and company that you get to interact with?

[00:51:18] Ryan Schnoke: Yeah. I think the biggest single thing is that where I'm at now, at this point, they care about what I think. They care about the opinions that I have, and they give me the freedom to do the analysis to come up with the right answer. Where the previous employer where we were at is they just wanted me to find a way to prove that what they thought was gonna work was a justifiable answer.

[00:51:45] So they knew where they wanted to go, they just needed something to support saying that's the way to go, even if it wasn't true. And so now we're really exploring and we're looking and we're making the right decision, even if it's the hard decision, and letting the data and the stories that it tell guide us to the right decision rather than trying to shoehorn it into what somebody thinks they wanna do.

[00:52:12] It's liberating. It makes me feel like I matter. Yeah. It makes me feel like the job that I'm doing is going to improve things for my fellow employees and for our customers at the same time, right? As well as our stockholders.

[00:52:27] And where I was at before, it had become all about the stockholders, period, end of statement. Didn't matter how it impacted the employees or the customers, to be honest. And the scary part is they have been through problems with that in the past, and they're headed right back towards it.

[00:52:43] Scott Anthony Barlow: I think there's a fun twist to this story too. Because your wife started looking at the same organization after, you know, hearing you come home and talk about its culture. And what happened?

[00:52:55] Ryan Schnoke: Yeah, and that almost makes it sound a little more grandiose than it was, to be honest, right? She was like, she heard me talking about it, and so yeah, exactly what you said, right?

[00:53:04] Like, "Oh, this sounds like an interesting company. It's not like the ones that I've worked for in the past." And she was self-employed. She was a real estate agent, self-employed. And enjoying that fairly well. Market's making it a little harder on real estate agents right now, but she was enjoying what she was doing.

[00:53:19] But she would listen to me and she said, "Huh, I wonder what other jobs Frost has." And so she went out and she looked and she found one, and she applied for one, and she got hired just like that. So it was a perfect fit for her, right? It was just a crazy later career journey of unexpected things that, through effort and perseverance, figured themselves out.

[00:53:43] Scott Anthony Barlow: This transition overall, what was that? Was it what you were talking about earlier, or just tell me a little bit about that.

[00:53:52] Ryan Schnoke: I think the most difficult part, really, because I had been where I was at so long, was just the unknown, and being able to have faith in myself that, oh yeah, it's different, but I can do it.

[00:54:07] And being able to rely on my faith to help me get through that as well. So I think those were big pieces, but I think that was really just the most difficult part, was being willing to face the unknown and do it with a good attitude. And maybe the attitude was the hardest part, right? I didn't say I wanted to be here, but I'm forced to be here, although I knew in the back of my head it was the best thing for me at that point.

[00:54:33] You still have somewhat of a negative attitude, like, "I can't believe you did this to me," right? So that's probably the hardest part, just letting go of that and saying, "Okay, yeah, you did something I didn't like to me, but I'm in the spot that I need to be in now to get where I wanna go." So just really reframing that experience to make it positive and empowering.

[00:54:56] Michael: If you want help with that, by the way, then I would love to invite you to drop me an email, scott@happentoyourcareer. Put 'Conversation' in the subject line, and I'll connect you with the right member of my team, and we'll have a conversation. We'll understand what you're trying to accomplish. We'll understand some of the concerns that you have and help you figure out how to navigate through your exact situation. It's what we do, and it's what we love to do. Until next time. I'm Scott, and this is Happen To Your Career. Adios. I'm out.

Ready for Career Happiness?

What Career Fits You?

Finally figure out what you should be doing for work

Join our 8-day “Mini-Course” to figure it out. It’s free!