770: How to Negotiate Your Own Job Offer: Write the Agreement, Set the Terms, and Don’t Settle

How to negotiate a job offer by setting your terms and writing the agreement, the way one co-founder did.

Listen

WATCH

what you’ll learn

  • How to negotiate a job offer by deciding your terms on flexibility, salary, and role scope before the conversation
  • Why Nancy turned down a contract role with total autonomy and flexibility, and why measuring offers against your old job keeps you settling
  • How she sat down with the owner, shared what she needed, and wrote the employment agreement herself
  • How she held her ground when the decision felt scary, with money and family expenses on the line
  • Why 14 months with almost no job applications is about right for work that fits

Success Stories

I had listened to the Happen To Your Career podcast for several years before reaching out to Scott about getting career coaching. I'd been in my role for nearly 10 years, wanted to stay, but felt like it was time to renegotiate. What I expected/hoped for was maybe a 10% raise MAX, as I was already near the top of my salary range for the area. Scott pushed me to ask for more, helped me feel confident I was worth that ask, and coached me through how that will probably go, what to say, when and how to say it, what not to say, etc. I walked into my boss's office prepared and he knew it. As my request went higher up the chain, they knew it as well. My preparations and HTYC's great coaching paid off, in a few week's turn around time I was given a 20% raise, and renegotiated job duties which will help me enjoy my job even more! I highly recommend both their podcast and coaching services, Scott and his team are the real deal!

Justin, Engineer

Exactly 5 weeks from when I arrived in Canada I got a full time job, negotiated a higher salary and within the next 3 days I got another offer that pays 33% more. I am happy and very thankful to you, for you gave me support when I was looking and offered great tips.

Ingrid , United States/Canada

[00:00:00] Nancy: Why am I letting somebody else decide my fate? Like, this just doesn't seem right.

[00:00:03] Scott Anthony Barlow: Nancy changed careers in 14 months, and almost none of that was spent applying to jobs.

[00:00:09] I felt more controlled and not having as much autonomy and freedom as I would like, both professionally and personally.So she left.

[00:00:18] Nancy: I needed a change. I needed to really spread my wings. It was probably the most difficult conversation of my life because we worked together for over 20 years.

[00:00:25] Scott Anthony Barlow: See, she ended up with two offers. Now, both of them were better than the job that she quit, but she turned one of them down. Now, the reason why is the really interesting part.

[00:00:35] Introduction: This is Happen To Your Career. Most people let their career happen to them, falling into jobs by accident, staying longer than they should, and wondering if this is really all there is. But a few people decide to stop settling and do something different. This podcast is for you to take control, get intentional, and design your career to fit the life that you want to build. Real stories and real research so you can stop waiting and start making it happen. I'm Scott Anthony Barlow.

[00:01:01] Scott Anthony Barlow: Nancy had 20 years in an event management company that she had co-founded. And most of it was as the operations leader in that organization.

[00:01:09] Nancy: Was a co-founder of the business but didn't really feel like I had a lot of the perks and benefits that go along with being a co-founder. I felt like life was just happening to me because I was just kind of following this path, and I wasn't really taking control. So we kind of hunkered down and did some online stuff, and then when that was over, I kind of took stock and decided that it was time for me to make a change.

[00:01:31] Scott Anthony Barlow: Now around year 15, she started wanting things, two things in particular, that she wasn't getting. Real control over how she led her team and then more time with her kids 'cause at the time her son was 15, her daughter was 14. She wanted to be able to be there for those high school years, and she could see this clock ticking.

[00:01:48] Nancy: I think part of the autonomy was professionally, internally, just having so many disagreements about how we manage and lead the team. It didn't feel authentic to me. I felt like I was, a lot of the times, trying to just fulfill his wishes and not really necessarily lead a team as I felt like I should. And that decision just really kinda, I guess, was the straw that broke the camel's back.

[00:02:08] It really became apparent to me that I was meant for more than just this one thing. That really pertained to spending time with my family and being there for them for baseball games or, you know, going to school events. It was just really hard for me to pull away and to feel okay pulling away, and it, that didn't feel good.

[00:02:24] Scott Anthony Barlow: Now, when somebody realizes that they've outgrown their work, what usually happens is they start running a job search, and they do less of the bad part, more of the missing parts, you know, shorter commute, better boss, better coworkers, more control, more money, whatever it is, right?

[00:02:39] And every one of those gets measured against the job that they were previously in. But what this means that most people don't realize is that they're already settling because the old job is the one that's setting that initial bar and setting the terms. You can still run that search perfectly and get to a better version than what you already have, and that's now creating the ceiling, not something that is extraordinary for you.

[00:03:02] Now, her full story's on the Happen To Your Career podcast, but the first offer that she got was a contract role, total autonomy, total flexibility, work when she wanted, everything that she walked out the door to get, and she passed. Her words on why? Well, the work itself was not at all challenging or stimulating in the way that she needed it.

[00:03:20] Nancy: I am huge into environmental conservation, and just the idea that I was helping builders clear forests so that they could build more homes, it kind of didn't sit well with me. I don't feel passion for helping these companies make money and profits. And the environment is not necessarily getting better because of it.

[00:03:37] But I don't often say this, but I was very proud of myself for sticking to my guns and not changing my mind, because there definitely were some moments over the months, because it was months, that there could have been opportunities for me to say, "oh, this is really hard. Forget it. I'll just stay."

[00:03:50] Scott Anthony Barlow: I want you to think about what that means. She solved for the exact variable that she left her previous job over. She got it, and if she had accepted that, she would've ended up with a worse life.

[00:04:03] Okay, so this other offer for Nancy was a COO role. It was harder. It was more complex. It was what she wanted to spend her time doing. But there were two problems, the flexibility and the money.

[00:04:15] Nancy: I have a lot of very expensive things happening with my kids' private sports and schools and everything else. So it was a challenge.

[00:04:23] Scott Anthony Barlow: Now, most people look at an offer like that and they either turn it down, keep on looking, or they accept it and hope that it's gonna turn out okay. What Nancy did is she sat down with the owner of the organization and shared with him what she needed, what she wanted flexibility to look like, and what she wanted the salary to be, what she wanted the role to include. And then she wrote up the entire thing, turned it into an employment agreement herself, brought it to him to sign.

[00:04:48] Nancy: It was a big decision. It was very scary. My husband honestly wasn't 100% like, "Yeah, we can do it," 'cause he's always very worrisome about, you know, money and what's gonna happen. But, again, proud of myself that I did not turn back,

[00:05:01] Scott Anthony Barlow: 14 months from start to signed agreement, almost none of it actually applying to jobs. Now, a lot of people might think 14 months sounds like a long time, and I would say that if we're considering that Nancy did what almost nobody in the world is actually doing, getting to fulfilling work that fits her, and she is really orchestrating the terms, I would say it's about right where it needs to be.

[00:05:22] If you wanna hear how Nancy went from a situation where she'd outgrown to her personal version of extraordinary, check out her story in her own words for what she did step by step on the Happen To Your Career podcast

[00:05:34] If you want help with that, by the way, then I would love to invite you to drop me an email, scott@happentoyourcareer. Put 'Conversation' in the subject line, and I'll connect you with the right member of my team, and we'll have a conversation. We'll understand what you're trying to accomplish. We'll understand some of the concerns that you have and help you figure out how to navigate through your exact situation. It's what we do, and it's what we love to do. Until next time, I'm Scott, and this is Happen To Your Career. Adios. I'm out.

Ready for Career Happiness?

What Career Fits You?

Finally figure out what you should be doing for work

Join our 8-day “Mini-Course” to figure it out. It’s free!